Can’t forgive yourself after abortion? Learn about 5 common beliefs that can keep you stuck and discover practical steps toward freedom and healing after abortion.
“Everyone tells me to, but I just can’t forgive myself since my abortion.”
A woman in one of our support groups shared those words years after her abortion experience. The details of her story were unique. The struggle wasn’t.
Maybe you’ve found yourself searching online for answers too.
How do I forgive myself after abortion?
Why can’t I forgive myself?
Will this guilt ever go away?
How do I heal after abortion?
Why do I still feel ashamed?
If you’ve asked yourself any of those questions, you’re not alone.
Women and men often reach a point where they realize the hardest part of healing after abortion isn’t always understanding or accepting what happened. Sometimes it’s learning how to live with themselves afterward.
They may carry guilt, shame, sadness, anger, grief, regret, confusion, relief, or emotions that are difficult to put into words. They may have talked with a counselor, joined a support group, prayed, journaled, or spent years trying to move forward.
Yet forgiving yourself after abortion can still feel frustratingly out of reach.
If that’s where you are, consider this possibility: the greatest obstacle to forgiving yourself may not be the experience itself. It may be the beliefs you’ve been carrying about yourself ever since.
Let’s look at five common beliefs that can quietly stand between forgiving yourself after abortion and greater healing, peace, and freedom.
Why Forgiving Yourself After Abortion Can Feel So Difficult
You may be carrying more than the experience itself.
When people talk about forgiving yourself after abortion, they often imagine a moment when everything suddenly clicks into place. One day the guilt is gone. The shame disappears. Peace arrives.
For most people, that’s not how it works.
Self-forgiveness is often a process. It grows through reflection, honesty, support, and a willingness to challenge beliefs that may have felt true for years.
As you read through these five common lies, notice which ones feel familiar. You may recognize one. You may recognize all five.
Awareness is often the first step toward healing. If you’re struggling with forgiving yourself after abortion, you may discover it has less to do with time and more to do with the beliefs you’ve continued carrying.
Forgiving Yourself After Abortion: Lie #1 — “I’ll Forgive Myself When I’ve Suffered Enough”
Where is the finish line?
Melissa* spent years carrying guilt after her abortion experience. Whenever life felt good, a familiar thought showed up: “You don’t deserve to feel okay.” She never said it out loud. She didn’t even realize how much it influenced her. Yet every time she experienced joy, success, or peace, part of her questioned whether she was worthy of it. Over time, she realized she had created an invisible finish line. Once she suffered enough, then she could forgive herself. The problem was that the finish line was never within reach.
You may recognize this pattern in your own life.
Perhaps you’ve spent years carrying emotional pain because it feels appropriate. Maybe guilt feels like proof that you care. Maybe part of you believes that peace belongs somewhere in the future, after you’ve paid a price.
Many people find themselves stuck in this cycle. They revisit old conversations. They replay circumstances. They return to the same questions again and again. Those mental loops can feel productive because they take up so much energy. Yet often, people discover they’re still asking themselves the same questions years later, without getting closer to peace.
Healing rarely arrives because you’ve accumulated enough suffering. Rather, it often begins when you stop requiring more pain in order to let go.
Ask Yourself
- What does “suffered enough” mean to me?
- How would I know when I’ve reached that point?
- What would make it difficult for me to accept peace if it arrived today?
Try This
Over the next few days, notice the moments when peace is available to you — something good happens, or you simply feel okay and something in you says “not yet,” a thought that says you haven’t earned this, that you’re not done paying.
You don’t have to argue with it or push it away. Just notice it’s there — and give yourself permission to see it as a thought, not a fact.
Forgiving Yourself After Abortion: Lie #2 — “If I Stop Hurting, It Means I Don’t Care”
You can care deeply and still make room for peace and forgiving yourself after abortion.
James* rarely talked about his abortion experience. Years had passed. He had a career, a family, and plenty of responsibilities. Most people who knew assumed he had moved on. Yet he often felt the weight of it all and replayed the events, memories, and feelings. “I need to remember,” he explained. Part of him had connected pain with caring. The hurt felt like proof that his abortion experience mattered.
Many women and men describe something similar. You may worry that healing means forgetting. Or that peace means the experience wasn’t important. Maybe you worry that letting go of feeling guilty somehow lessens what happened or how you felt.
Yet caring and suffering are two different things. You can remember an experience without being defined by it. You can honor an experience without carrying shame about it. You can care deeply and still make room for healing.
Sometimes the pain connected to abortion experiences starts shaping the way you see yourself. Over time, you may shift from thinking, “I had this experience” to “This is who I am.” Brené Brown talks about how guilt focuses on something you did or experienced. But shame says, “There’s something wrong with me.” And shame makes self-forgiveness much harder.
Healing invites a different possibility.
Ask Yourself
- What does my pain keep me holding on to?
- What might happen if the pain became lighter?
- What would it mean to remember without carrying the same weight?
Try This
Imagine, just for a moment, that the pain felt lighter tomorrow. Not gone, just lighter.
Then consider: if it hurt less, would the love, the meaning, the importance of your abortion experience(s) disappear with the pain? Or would they still be there — just without the weight?
Why Self-Blame Makes Forgiving Yourself After Abortion Harder: Lie #3 — “I Should Have Known Better”
Looking back changes the view.
Briana* often replays the same thought: “What was I thinking?” Years had passed since her abortion experience. Looking back now, she sees things differently. She recognizes fears she hadn’t fully understood at the time. She’s aware of resources she wishes she had known about then. She acknowledges how much pressure she was under. She realizes she often evaluates her younger self through the lens of everything she has learned since then.
You may be doing the same thing.
It can be easy to look back with what you know or think today and wonder why your younger self didn’t see things the way you do now. Articles about regret and hindsight often point out how commonly people revisit the past with today’s knowledge, perspective, and maturity.
Yet your past self only had access to that moment. That version of you carried a specific set of circumstances, pressures, fears, beliefs, and resources. It’s easy to forget how different life looked from where you were standing then. When you expect your younger self to possess the wisdom you’ve gained since, the outcome can be harsh self-blame.
When you begin viewing your lived experience more honestly and more completely, your compassion for yourself can grow.
Ask Yourself
- What was I facing at the time — pressures, fears, limits?
- What do I know now that I had no way of knowing back then?
- What would feel different if I stopped expecting that earlier version of me to have known the future?
Try This
The next time you catch yourself thinking “I should have known better,” pause and ask “better how?” — with what you actually knew then, or with what you only know now? Let the question sit, and see what you notice.
Self-Forgiveness After Abortion: Lie #4 — “Other People Deserve Compassion. I Don’t.”
Would you speak to a friend the way you speak to yourself?
Rachel* volunteered assisting unhoused people, supported friends through difficult seasons, and listened without judgment whenever someone needed help. Compassion came naturally to her—for others. “If a friend or someone else told me they were carrying this, I’d have nothing but compassion for her,” she shared. “But I just can’t seem to find any for myself.”
Maybe you’ve experienced that too. Many people extend grace freely to others while withholding it from themselves.
Researcher Kristin Neff’s work on self-compassion suggests that offering yourself the same understanding you’d offer a friend can create space for healing and growth. Yet that can be a lot easier said than done. In fact, this may be one of the biggest obstacles to forgiving yourself after abortion.
You probably wouldn’t tell a hurting friend that she was beyond healing, or that she should carry guilt, shame, or other hard emotions for the rest of her life. So why are you so much harsher on yourself? The compassion you offer others belongs to you too.
Ask Yourself
- What would I say to a friend with my exact story?
- What do I say to myself instead?
- What would it be like to offer myself even a little of what I would offer her?
Try This
Think of a time you comforted someone who was being hard on themselves — a friend convinced she’d ruined everything or someone certain she was beyond forgiving. Recall what you saw in her that she didn’t see at the time: that she was hurting, that she was more than one moment, that she deserved kindness.
Now try saying those same things to yourself. If it feels harder, sit with that for a minute — the kindness you offered her so easily is the same kindness you are allowed to give yourself.
Forgiving Yourself After Abortion: Lie #5 — “Forgiveness Has to Be Earned”
You are the gatekeeper for self-forgiveness.
David* spent years trying to make up for his abortion experience with a past girlfriend. He worked hard. He showed up for others. He volunteered. He tried to be the best husband and father he could be. These were good things. Yet underneath them was a belief he rarely acknowledged: If he became good enough, maybe then he could forgive himself.
Many people carry some version of this belief. Perhaps you’ve tried to earn forgiveness through achievement. Or helping others. Or through years of guilt.
The challenge is that forgiveness doesn’t arrive through a scorecard.
Many conversations about self-forgiveness emphasize honesty, accountability, and compassion. These qualities work together. They create room to acknowledge what happened while also allowing growth and healing.
Here’s what makes self-forgiveness different: no one else is standing between you and peace. The person you’ve been waiting to forgive you, and the person who can, are the same — you.
That’s the trap in trying to earn it: peace stays one step ahead, because you keep raising the bar on yourself. And it’s also the way out. The forgiveness you’ve been waiting to be granted is already yours to give.
Ask Yourself
- What have I been doing to try to make up for it — and has any amount ever felt like enough?
- Has all the effort I’ve put in brought me any peace — or just more things to do?
- What would it feel like to stop working for self-forgiveness and simply grant it to myself?
Try This
Think about the last time you tried to earn forgiveness — the last time you over-gave, over-apologized, threw yourself into being good enough.
Picture what you were hoping it would finally settle. Did it? Or did you just find the next thing you needed to do before you could forgive yourself?
Sometimes the next step toward freedom is setting down the scorecard altogether. Peace doesn’t have to wait for one more accomplishment, one more good deed, or one more year of carrying guilt. You may discover that the hardest part isn’t becoming worthy of forgiveness. It’s believing that you already are.
Practical Steps Toward Freedom and Forgiving Yourself After Abortion
Healing after abortion rarely follows a straight line. The same is true for forgiving yourself after abortion.
Some days may feel lighter than others. Some seasons may bring new insights. Others may bring old emotions back into view.
As you continue your journey, consider these practical steps:
- Notice the stories you tell yourself about your abortion experience(s).
- Pay attention to expectations that keep healing farther away.
- Separate caring from suffering.
- View past experiences through the realities of that season of life.
- Offer yourself the same compassion you would offer someone you love.
- Allow accountability and healing to exist together.
- Reach out for support when the burden feels too heavy to carry alone.
You don’t have to master all of these today.
One small step is enough.
Your Next Step Toward Freedom and Healing After Abortion
If you’ve been struggling with forgiving yourself after abortion, you may have recognized one or more of these beliefs in your own story.
Perhaps you’ve been waiting until you’ve suffered enough. Maybe you’ve been carrying pain because it feels connected to caring. Or you might have been judging a younger version of yourself through the lens of everything you’ve learned since then. Maybe you’ve offered everyone else compassion while quietly deciding you’re the exception. Or perhaps you’ve been trying to earn forgiveness without realizing it.
Whatever resonated with you, consider this: You don’t have to solve self-forgiveness today.
Healing often begins with awareness. It grows through honesty, support, reflection, and a willingness to gently challenge the stories that have shaped the way you see yourself.
As you reflect on your own experiences, consider:
- Which of these beliefs feels most familiar to me?
- What would become possible if I loosened my grip on that belief?
- What might greater freedom look like in my life?
If you’re looking for support, we’re here to help.
After Abortion Line
A safe, anonymous, and compassionate space to talk about your abortion experiences. Call or text 844-289-HOPE (4673) or visit supportafterabortion.com.
Healing Support Groups and Mentors
Connect in a group or one-on-one setting, depending on your comfort level. We offer choices including religious and secular, virtual and in-person, peer-led and counseling-based support for women and men.
Self-Guided and Group Resources
Keys to Hope and Healing — A compassionate, secular resource designed to help women and men work through emotions that can follow abortion experiences. Available in English and Spanish, with companion journals and self-guided videos.
Finding Solid Ground: A Man’s Guide to Healing After Abortion — A faith-based resource for men seeking healing after abortion. Through real stories, practical tools, and reflections on God’s love and mercy, men can explore their experiences and move toward healing and hope.
Unraveled Roots — Sometimes abortion experiences intersect with deeper wounds such as abandonment, addiction, abuse, or codependency. Unraveled Roots helps women and men explore those underlying issues and discover healthier ways forward.
Forgiving yourself after abortion is rarely a single moment. For many people, it’s a gradual process of making room for compassion, releasing old burdens, and carrying their experiences in a new way. Often, that’s where freedom begins.
© Support After Abortion
*Names and identifying details have been changed to protect privacy. Some stories represent themes commonly shared by clients.
We always welcome your feedback! If something in this blog struck a chord—or left you thinking—feel free to share your thoughts anonymously here or send us an email.
